*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*

Wednesday, May 25, 2005

Malaysian Idol, Akademi Fantasi, Audition - antara kemampuan sebenar, dan pilihan peminat...

Dearest all...



Since demam reality shows nih kembali, sekembalinya Akademi Fantasi musim ke-3 nih, I thought of writing something regarding this... saje je ubah angin; tulis bab bab happenings in town, kan? :)



Personally - I do watch all these stuffs, tapi, tak mengikuti sangat la kan perkembangannye; kire macam, on and off aje la mek ikuti perkembangan all these reality singing/ talent shows nih. MI, I watched dedekat nak habis dah - tu pun sebelum2 tu, kalau ade news apa apa pon, by gossip aje. Audition 1, tgk la jugak sikit2 - tapi bile start part berlakon tu - I would normally switch to another channel, and AF1 - tgk sikit2. AF2 however - mek tgk banyak sikit if nak compared to AF1. Sebabnye? Ade lah sebab2 nye... Ehehe - ok ok! Sebab ade Kaer itiew. Cute sangat.

Kaer Kaer Kaer... haiiiii... cairrr...


Eheheheh... Apa apa pon, back to the topic here - the main issue dalam entry nih is this...

"Pilihan/ Undian penonton/ peminat; adakah sama dengan kemampuan mereka dalam arena seni suara tanahair?"

I know I am not in the correct position to talk about this tapi just to sembang2; wouldn't you agree, ape yang dipilih/ yang menang - sometimes, atas dasar "suka" or "minat" or "syiok" or sebab contestant tu cute ke handsome ke lawa ke cun ke ape ke - dan bukan berdasarkan kemampuan peserta reality show itiew? For instance - AI (American Idol) - tu, sape tu namanye tu, alaaa, ha.. si La Toya London itiew - Mek very the sedeh pilu teratai layu ditasik kelana jaya, bile dapat tau dia tersingkir - based on pilihan, votes - dia tercampak kuar di peringkat ke berape tah (punye lah jahil tak tahu menahu hal2 nih. LOL!) - Walhal si La Toya itiew (mengingatkan kiew kepada La Toya Jackson la pulak) - dia lah yang diwar warkan sebagai the next AI, diexpectedkan sebagai pemenangnye. Dah ler suara power, rupa pong ade (sweet) - tapi, itu la dia, dikatakan the power of votes, kan? Isk - mek pilu... Syahdu bile nengok dia tersingkir itiew...

But don't get me wrong - I'm not saying yang dah menang segala AF1, AF2, Audition 1, MI 1, and so forth tu semuanye tak bagus menyanyi - semuanye terror ok, masing2 ade bakat! Respect sgt2 si Jac MI 1 itiew - suara, haiyoh!!!! Lantang! Siape nak jawab? Tapi at the same time - Dina pon (the Runner up), ala ala va va voom jugak, kan? Ha, itu, how to jawab?

Jac and Dina - rentap berentap di malam finals Malaysian Idol!


I guess all am trying to say here is that - pilhan, or undian kite tu, memang penting, memang perlu diambil kire. Namun begitu, adakah our right choice is the best choice? Hmmm - or is it the other way round; adekah pilihan terbaik kite itu, the right choice? Think about it. Lets...

Ape motif ade juri professional? Sekadar nak kasik pandapat dan pandangan aje ke? I still say that pilihan kite, viewers, memang penting - but don't you think, by allowing us to vote and the results are based 100% on our votes tu, macam, tah lah - I shouldn't be saying this but then, ape pointnye ade juri?

Owh Abang Roslankiew... hehehehehe...


Maybe dah banyak orang persoalkan hal ini - dan mek ala ala slow coach jer baru nak sentuh hal perihal reality shows nih kan - akan tetapi, its like what they say, it's never too late. So - comments2 anda amatlah diperlukan - dan tersangatlah dihargai. So tunggu ape lagi, lets start commenting kat my comment entry area bawah itiew. Ehehehehe...

Mek also nak masuk lahhh AF ke MI ke - lip sync aje lah, can ah? Ehehehe... suara betoi? Haiyoh! Maaati la mek! Ehehehe


**************************************************************

Nak comment pasal ape nih!!!? Ape topicnye?!
"Reality Shows - antara kemampuan sebenar peserta, dan pilihan hati peminat2"

How to comment, tak paham concept lah...? Cerita sikit...
"Cam nih - dalam comment area tu - just voice out lar what you think about all this reality shows - tak kire lah AI ke, MI ke AF ke ape ke - janji - what do you personally think about all this? Should reality shows give 100% hak kepada peminat utk vote? And if that's the case - adekah juara/ pemenang itu, layak, based on kemampuan serta bakat sendirian berhad, or just menang sebab vote? And if 100% pemilihan diberi kepada penonton serta peminat, don't you think we shoulc skip the juri2 professional? Kalau ade setakat kasik komen - hmmm.. cam ne? - haaa.. gittu2 lar..."

Apa apa pon leh cakap ke kat sini? Nak komen ape2 pon, boleh ek?
"Dinch! Comment2 berunsur kutukan, henaan dan cacian tidak dibenarkan sama sekali u ols. Nak voice out pendapat, boleh - just related to the issue. Peribadi - persoal - semua tu.. ADDINCH!"

Zahid De La Orange - Juara AF Musim Ke-2 - First class! Ehehehe


Bagi mereka yang nak ikuti perkembangan dunia Akademi Fantasia musim ke 3 nih - here are some links u ols leh go about and check things out:

Lepas2 nih mek nak buat entry tribute to those yang dinch menang pulak, can ah? Ehehehehe - Kaer (Kaer laggi.. ehehe), Dina, erm... La Toya London.. ekekek - nantikan yer? Tunggu... Ekekeke!


Nurlea Laurielle Lai Lee Abdullah
Like my page? Vote for me HERE!!! Thanks u ols!!!





Posted at 2:19:12 pm by Nurlea Laurielle Lai Lee Abdullah

shay
May 25, 2005   04:49 PM PDT
 
kaer best!

mender reality singing competition nie arap2 takde le produce artis mee segera...cth AF1nye bebudak org dah lupa bila kuar AF2....nak carik penyanyi tapi most of 'em ended up jadik pelakon le, tukang bukak kotak le dj le...sometimes defeats the purpose of finding a great entertainer..

tgk jelah...w/pun kuasa di tangan kita tapi still it's up to them nak jadik apa..
Eva
May 25, 2005   05:26 PM PDT
 
HI Kak Lea...whassup??

Ok lets start ngan AF la ekk....
Eva comment pasal pemenang and some of the peserta la ekk...

AF1 : Suka Vince...suara dia besh...
AF2 : Suka Zahid, suara dia pon not bad...
AI 1 :Kelly Clarkson beshhhhh
AI2 : Ruben ... ermm actually lebih suker Clay Aiken
MI 1: Suka dua-dua...Jac and Dina...masing2 beshh

Pasal La Toya kan...for me..suara dia biasa...like u say u teringat La Toya Jackson kan...so maknanya kat America dah ada suara macam dia. American Idol want to find someone unique that American don't have yet......

Pasal vote pasal minat, suka, head over heels tue, for example.....Malaysiaon Idol 1......nak tahu sapa....Saiful.....ingat Saiful x? Muka dia sweet but bakat...ermm I don't think so....byk org vote dia bukan berdasarkan voice but muka.....

Sekian
katadah.warriors
May 27, 2005   08:53 AM PDT
 
tapi, for malaysian IDOL, i LOOOVVVEEEE sufiah and zameer.. they have this powerful voice.. rasanye, kalau duet.. haruss hazzab.. runtuh guthrie pavillion kat SA nih uols..
BadarSila
May 28, 2005   08:49 AM PDT
 
mek suke topik nih.. 4 reality shows esp the singing thingy, mek tgk yg disiarkan kt saluran yg free je ler, kalo AF tu tgk sket2 je sbb x mampu beli astro, so tumpang tgk kt umah member je sblm ni hehe..

mak nk komen psl fungsi voters dan juri, voters penting sbb sblm these contestants kuar sbg recording artist, pihak penganjur nk expose diorg dulu, so biar kuar album, xde la org tertanya2 sapa artis itieww... sodrp votes nih, depa tgk lak sapa yg plg ramai peminat, so bila kuar album nnt xder la masalah album xlaku ke hapa kan, so that's y voters r very2 important...

mcm juri plak, komen2 diorg tu penting utk improve performance contestants itieww.. maksudnya contestants akn improve their next performance lps dgr komen2 juri itieww, itupon kalo diorg x voted out la kan, lg 1 fungsi juri ni penting masa mula2 nk pilih finalis, maksudnya diorg kene pilih yg betul2 "berbakat", tp kdg2 mak tgk finalis2 tu xder la bakat sgt tp ada rupa, tgk la apa kriteria2 yg juri nak kan, so itu je la komen mak yg serba "ringkas" hehe... ala2 kalo soalan ni kuar masa Q&A beauty pageant mak leh menang x uols? hiks...



Leave a Comment:

Name


Homepage (optional)


Comments




Previous Entry Home Next Entry